Some of Arizona's most Successful Agents call John Hall & Associates home.

How accurate are Zestimates in Phoenix?

So I was checking out a great post by Arizona Real Estate Agent Elizabeth Newlin on the AAR Blog yesterday.  In it she referred to Zillow as a jolly green giant toe sucker.  Hilarious.

Along comes the newly named CEO of Zillow Spencer Rascoff to comment on Elizabeth’s impressive insult which opened a quick back and forth between the two.

In the dialog, Spencer acknowledges “Agents and Appraisals will always be more accurate than a computer model.” and he shared a link to the Zestimate Accuracy Reports.

Phoenix Metro Area received an accuracy rating of 2 out of 4 stars.  Here are the numbers…

Zestimate Accuracy in Phoenix, Arizona

Within 5% of Sales PriceWithin 10% of Sales PriceWithin 20% of Sales Price
20%38%61%

Pretty cool response from the CEO if you ask me.

3 Responses to How accurate are Zestimates in Phoenix?
  1. James Wehner
    October 4, 2010 | 8:20 am

    Thanks for this posting!

    This really cracks me up! I think any homeowner and/ or prospective buyer can guess what a homes value should be within 20% of the sales price. And to think that Zillow is only 61% accurate at being within 20% of the sales price. That’s pretty bad if you ask me.

    This is good news for Realtors and Appraisers. We ARE still needed!!! ;)

  2. Elizabeth Newlin
    October 25, 2010 | 3:08 pm

    I just saw this, thanks for the link! I loved that comment by Spencer, too. It makes me so happy when people have a sense of humor about themselves. :D

    • Phil Sexton
      October 25, 2010 | 3:54 pm

      My pleasure! Your articles are great…

Leave a Reply