Local real estate broker, Jim Sexton, spoke at the Scottsdale Luxury Home Tour yesterday. He shared a plethora of statistics with the group, focused on luxury homes over a million dollars. Here are some of the numbers he presented.
As we head into September, let’s review ARMLS Closed numbers Year to Date (YTD) and compare them to 2008 to identify trends.
Here are the numbers for 2008 and 2009 as the FBS system reports as of 8/27/2009.

So what are some noteworthy trends?
#1 we have closed more transactions in 2009 in 8 months than we did for all of 2008. That’s a significant increase! Where did the increases come from?
REO’s have spent most of the year up almost double from last years percentages; 34% for all of 2008, currently 61% YTD 2009, but Pendings show that % coming down (42%).
Short Sales (SS) have increased dramatically also and continue to be increasing. 2008 had only 2% of closings as SS. Currently 12% of 2009 YTD closings are SS, with Pendings totaling 28%. This doesn’t even account for the +5000 SS that are in AWC statuses.
Vacant properties continue to account for a large % of all closings; up 9% from 2008′s 76%. Pendings show Vacants dropping which is good news for sellers living in their houses as well as builders, whose buyers are waiting for their houses to sell.
Reviewing the prices figures shows a drop of 32% for the average sales price and a 35% drop for the median. Again this is comparing all of 2008 to YTD 2009. 2008 started the year @ $313,000 as the Average for January and ended with $192,900 in December. These just happened to be the high and the low months, with the average for the year coming in at $248,000. 2009 started @ $180,000 in January with August MTD @ $169,000. The range is $159,000 to 180,000 with the average @ $168,000.
The Median for 2008 started @ $220,000 and ended @ $150,000 – which was also the range. The Median for 2008 was $189,500. 2009 started @ 130,000, bottomed in April @ $115,500-and is currently at $122,500 YTD.
So what does all this mean? It would appear that supply and demand have arrived in the Valley and are not being ignored. However there is still a ‘tale of 2 markets’ with the price break around $400,000. The supply of properties is less than 6 months under $400,000 and climbs well over 6 months above. Properties need to be priced well to sell and appraise.
2009 will probably be the 3rd highest year for closings this decade, behind only 2004′s 98,900 and 2005′s 104,700. Yes read that one again! The Average Sales price and the Median may be the lowest of the decade. Right now-2009 is tracking with 2001 and 2002 figures.
Short Sales are trending up and REO’s are trending down. However, there are still 47,000 properties currently in Foreclosure and that number did ‘shoot up’ for the first 4 months this year. 2008 saw a +16000 increase in ‘Pending’ Foreclosures (from 15,000 to 31,000) and 2009 matched that increase through the end of July. The number of Bank Owned properties has actually decreased by 3000 (33000 sold versus 30000 foreclosed) through July in 2009.
Just when I thought Ruff’s Reports had been permanently replaced with Orr’s Observations, Mr. Tom Ruff of the Information Market hit Send/Receive. In his latest Housing Report, Tom takes on Zillow, Yahoo, and he lets us know this is the last email to expect. All further commentary will be distributed through the subscription service on the Cromford Report. God Bless Tom Ruff and his pompoms.
Let’s review May 2009:
Initial May Closings- 9238; Average Sale price $165,500; Median Price $120,000
Let’s Compare April 2009 to May:
Closings +8% (every month this year has shown an increase); Avg SP- UP $5800 or +4% 2nd increase in a row after basically 22 months in a row of declining Avg SP; Median Price UP $4500 or 4% again after 22 months of decline.
Let’s compare May 2009 with May 2008:
5/9 Closings UP 63%; Avg SP down 39%; Median SP down 41%.
Let’s review YTD:
YTD: Jan-May 2008-21,188
YTD: Jan-May 2009-35,657 or plus 68%
May 2009 was also the 12th month in a row of Same Month/Yearly increases. These 12 increases follow 32 months of Same Month/ Yearly decreases.
But do these numbers tell the whole story? Noooo, there are so many pocket markets and so many REO’s and short sales to account for. Tune in later this week for the Rest of the Story.
Can you believe another week has gone by!? I’m not sure all the dust has settled from last weeks Flexmls Feature Friday. That’s okay by me – keep the questions coming. It’s what has led to this weeks F³. Here’s the story (don’t mind the subtle marketing)…
Cheryl Watson, long-time Valley agent who just transferred to John Hall & Associates, decided to take advantage of the most knowledgeable brokers in the Valley four hours after her paperwork was finalized. She called up with 3 questions; about our intranet, her website, and market statistics. All normal questions I like to answer. The first two – standard operating procedures. Then the curve ball. She was looking for condo statistics for a specific zip code. As of late the Cromford Report has been the go-to for all my statistics. I walked her through getting signed up for the free trial version only to find his reports are primarily focused on Single Family Residences and/or the entire market. We couldn’t find condo stats broken down by zip code. Stumped. Other than running the numbers and building the charts herself, I thought she was out of luck.
About a half hour went by before I got an educational phone call from Bryan Jones with the Talon Group. He told me he too had a conversation with Cheryl and he was able to find what she was looking for. His answer has led to this weeks f-cubed.
Have you seen the iMapp sidebar lately?
I really like the term digital curator. There is so much information available on the web, it’s a valuable service to have someone find the good stuff and display it in an organized format. I try to do that for you. Today, I received and email from an agent who did it for me. Wonderfully helpful.
No reinventing wheels around here…
Phil,
Here’s an e-mail I sent to some clients, who are just now realizing they have to pay above list price:
I’ve been reporting the changes in the Phoenix real estate market for a few months now. Other agents are adding their observations too.
Phoenix homes have now had 7 consecutive weeks of increased median sales prices. From a low of $162,717 in early April to this week’s $173,909, a price increase of almost 7% in less than 2 months! The number of Phoenix home listings has dropped 30% since January. More details here:
http://uglyhousephotos.com/wordpress/?p=9087
I analyzed the sales data from April for the entire Phoenix metro area. A market with a 6-month supply of homes is considered a balanced market (buyer-seller). February and before, we were seeing 9-12 months of inventory, a buyer’s market. That number dropped to 5.2 months in April, with homes only down to 4.6; that’s a seller’s market; May will turn out even lower. Charts & details here:
http://uglyhousephotos.com/wordpress/?p=9036
The LA Times reported on Sunday that Phoenix real estate went from bust to boom, with multiple offers now:
http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-phoenix18-2009may18,0,7979477.story
This agent found that the available inventory of bank-owned foreclosure listings went from a 3.6 month supply a few months ago to only a ONE month supply today. Today there are only half the number of available foreclosure listings we had 3 months ago. That’s why we’re seeing multiple offers:
http://www.phoenixrealestateguy.com/sunday-stats-a-look-at-bank-owned-homes-in-phoenix/2306
This agent also found that list prices are starting to go up, not down:
(Article has been removed)
I hope this information helps explain why things seem crazy in real estate right now.
Thank you,
Leif Swanson, Realtor, John Hall & Associates
I attended a Market Review by Mike Orr last Wednesday. Mike is the analyst behind the Cromford Report. If you are an ARMLS subscriber, I recommend that after reading this article you go immediately to his site and sign up for your FREE subscription to his market stats. I’ll give you a preview of what’s available.
Mike compared different methods for tracking or measuring prices. He said that average sales prices were skewed upwards by luxury homes; median prices are skewed downward by low-end REO’s; Case-Shiller index analyzes “pairs”(same house selling twice) which are infrequent and delayed 60 days minimum. So he concludes that an average sales price/square foot is the best compromise. Naturally he has charts tracking those numbers.
This chart shows the market has ended its steep decline and is attempting to stabilize and possibly bump up. The average price per square foot has actually started up in some of the outlying cities which were the hardest hit price wise last year.
Other interesting observations show active listings dropping 10,000 in the last 2 months.
Current ARMLS actives are less than 41,000.
Current Pending sales are the highest ever recorded-let’s say that again the HIGHEST EVER RECORDED yes that includes 2004 and 2005.
And it’s interesting to see the trend of sales per month spread out instead of stacked by month like ARMLS does it.
Yes the numbers might be the same (or similar- Mike updates his even after the fact) but seeing them trend up and down tells the story of the “recovery” we have seen since 12/07.
His entire presentation is available on the John Hall & Associates Intranet. Or just go to his site and explore yourself. There’s great information for you and your clients. Thanks Mike-great job.